Non­fic­tion

The Col­ors of Zion: Blacks, Jews, and Irish from 1845 – 1945

George Born­stein
  • Review
By – August 29, 2011
For the past thir­ty years or so, cul­tur­al stud­ies have tend­ed to empha­size dif­fer­ence rather than iden­ti­ty. Such a focus has led to divi­sive iden­ti­ty pol­i­tics that can­not com­pre­hend the rich­ness of the dia­logue that devel­oped among many groups because of the fer­tile com­mon ground on which each stood. In this fas­ci­nat­ing and per­sua­sive study, Born­stein, the C.A Patrides Pro­fes­sor of Lit­er­a­ture, Emer­i­tus, at the Uni­ver­si­ty of Michi­gan, demon­strates that over the 100-year peri­od between 1845 and 1945, the coop­er­a­tive sym­pa­thies among Blacks, Jews, and Irish were deeply root­ed and strong and that these areas of coop­er­a­tion over­shad­owed the real dif­fer­ences and ten­sions that exist­ed among these groups.

Rang­ing over a wide array of mate­ri­als from George Eliot’s Daniel Deron­da and James Joyce’s Ulysses to Zora Neale Hurston’s Moses, Man of the Moun­tain, the film The Jazz Singer, and the speech­es of Fred­er­ick Dou­glass, Born­stein allows the indi­vid­u­als involved to speak for them­selves. His project recov­ers a broad and his­tor­i­cal record of what Blacks, Jews, and Irish them­selves said and did rather than imag­in­ing their reac­tions and then pro­ject­ing them from the present back to the past. Thus, he explores, among oth­er exam­ples, the delib­er­ate invo­ca­tion of the Irish Renais­sance of W.B. Yeats and John Syn­ge as a mod­el for the Harlem Renais­sance of Alain Locke and James Wel­don John­son, the sup­port of Pan– African lib­er­a­tion move­ments for Jew­ish ones, and the pub­li­ca­tion by the same large­ly new and Jew­ish New York pub­lish­ing hous­es of the lit­er­a­ture
of all three groups. Bornstein’s bril­liant com­par­a­tive and transat­lantic study com­pels us to rethink the rela­tion­ship among races and the ways that we can learn from the exam­ples he dis­cuss­es in such lumi­nous detail.
Hen­ry L. Car­ri­g­an, Jr. writes about books for Pub­lish­ers Week­ly, Library Jour­nal, Book­Page, and Fore­Word. He has writ­ten for numer­ous news­pa­pers includ­ing the Atlanta Jour­nal-Con­sti­tu­tion, The Char­lotte Observ­er, The Cleve­land Plain Deal­er, The Orlan­do Sen­tinel, The Chris­t­ian Sci­ence Mon­i­tor, and The Wash­ing­ton Post Book World.

Discussion Questions