Churchill's Promised Land: Zionism and Statecraft
Yale University Press
With his extensive and intimate knowledge of Churchill, Gilbert draws the more personal and expansive picture. He recreates exchanges—conversations, as recorded in diaries and archives, and correspondence— between Churchill and many of the leading Zionists, from Weizmann to Vladimir Jabotinsky to David Ben-Gurion, and the warmth that often marked them. Makovsky approaches Churchill’s Zionism more analytically, trying to understand the place of what he calls Churchill’s sentimental support of Zionism in his overriding goal of preserving British power and security and Western civilization.
As prime minister of Britain during its most desperate hours, Churchill had to give his full energies to winning the war and to establishing a peace that ensured Britain’s strategic and political goals. These goals sometimes subordinated the goals of the Zionists, and Churchill at times turned from them. In the end, however, both authors agree that Churchill was, in his own words, “a Zionist,...one of the original ones,” who fought mightily for the Jewish state. In addition to giving a rich picture of Churchill’s support of Zionism, both books also describe the political struggles in the British government over the creation of Israel, which make the establishment of the state even more remarkable.
Additional Books Featured in this Review
Churchill liked to judge which events were historically significant and which were not, and both early in his career and near the end of it he declared the restoration of a Jewish state in the Holy Land to be of exceptional historical significance. Eventually, Zionism became very dear to him and integral to his worldview, and he supported it at great political cost, contributing to his unpopularity among his colleagues and other members of the political and government establishment.
The Beginnings of Churchill's Promised Land
By Michael Makovsky
My book is based on a few chapters of my history doctoral dissertation at Harvard on Churchill’s worldview, but the doctorate turned out to be only the beginning of a decade-long journey—one that was most stimulating and consuming.
The book’s subject, which was suggested by one of my professors, combined two longstanding interests: Zionism and Winston Churchill’s approach to world affairs. Israel was always important to my family as I was growing up, as was foreign affairs and politics. Indeed, we often spoke of those matters, as well as sports, at the dinner table. After studying history in college, I got a MBA and worked at energy trading companies. But after twice reading Churchill’s six-volume WWII memoirs and some biographies of him on a commuter train, I decided to go back and get a PhD in diplomatic history.
I began working on the book shortly after getting my doctorate, and it became for me a passionate cause. The more I researched the more I became fascinated by Churchill’s complex, evolving, multidimensional relationship with the relatively new and unusual cause of Zionism, which largely appealed to the romantic side of this so-called ‘realist.’ I came to understand how Churchill helped shape the modern Middle East, contributed to the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948 (60 years ago this spring), and what his complex relationship with Zionism meant for his world outlook.
Churchill summed up the book-writing experience well and most colorfully in 1949, “Writing a book is an adventure. To begin with, it is a toy, and an amusement; then it becomes a mistress, and then it becomes a master, and then a tyrant. The last phase is that just as you are about to be reconciled to your servitude, you kill the monster, and fling him about to the public.”
1. Who influenced Churchill's view of Jews?
2. What were some of the reasons Churchill became a Zionist, and when?
3. Why did Churchill sometimes ignore or oppose Zionist issues?
4. What were some of Churchill's pro-Zionist objectives in World War II?
5. On balance, was Churchill good for the Jews and Zionists?