Banned Books, Crop Tops and Other Bad Influences is a middle-grade novel about the classic themes of young adolescence — changing friendships, worries about appearance, fitting in and popularity, clashes with parents, and adapting to a rapidly changing internal and external world. At the beginning of the book, Rose, a thirteen-year-old Jewish girl, encounters Talia, a girl from New York who has moved to the small Michigan town where Rose has lived all her life. Talia is in Rose’s class at school and belongs to the same synagogue, but rumor has it that Talia is a girl who gets into a lot of trouble. Talia has a rocky start at school and seems to be living up to her rebellious reputation when she challenges their history teacher about the American bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
Talia is a rebel but also a thinker. “Things don’t have to be just the way things are,” she tells Rose. Talia introduces Rose to a novel about the German transatlantic liner St. Louis, a ship carrying Jewish refugees to the United States that is sent back to Germany in 1939. Rose subsequently learns that the book is not on her school’s approved reading list, and she reluctantly defies her parents and school to join a banned-book club that Talia is launching.
Rose’s developing friendship with Talia changes Rose’s place in her small-town culture. It creates a rift with her lifelong best friend Charlotte, changes what Rose chooses to wear, and affects which friends she hangs out with. These changes mean that Rose is growing up, but is she doing so in healthy ways?
This is a book about early adolescence, friendship, and about standing up for one’s values. Talia, Rose, and Charlotte are strong characters, and their triumphs and struggles will be of interest to many middle grade readers.