Chil­dren’s

Hono­ria: A For­tu­itous Friendship

December 12, 2024

When Ida is sent away for the sum­mer to stay with the Mur­phys — friends of her father, but also of Zel­da and Scott Fitzger­ald — she trav­els from New York to France and, unknow­ing­ly, into the artis­tic epi­cen­ter of 1929. There, she meets their haughty, sullen, and pre­co­cious daugh­ter, Hono­ria, and won­ders if she can be friends with the pret­ti­est girl in the whole world. In the per­fect invert­ed world” of adults, one of con­stant play and leisure — and ine­bri­a­tion, of course — it’s the chil­dren who most acute­ly per­ceive the per­va­sive unhap­pi­ness bub­bling beneath the sur­face gaiety.

Aching­ly sad and effort­less­ly fun­ny, full of the kind of youth­ful sin­cer­i­ty uncloud­ed by pre­tens­es of age, short sto­ry writer and car­toon­ist Jan­ice Shapiro’s debut graph­ic nov­el, Hono­ria, is the com­plex sto­ry of the edu­ca­tion of two young girls who have start­ed mov­ing slow­ly into womanhood.

Discussion Questions

Jan­ice Shapiro’s Hono­ria is spe­cial for the can­did, straight­for­ward, and hon­est way it nav­i­gates a com­plex friend­ship between two young girls. Seen through the eyes of pre-teen Ida, Hono­ria has all the trap­pings of his­tor­i­cal inter­est: lit­er­ary and artis­tic lumi­nar­ies like Zel­da and Scott Fitzger­ald, a lan­guid sum­mer in the south of France, the fraugh­t­ness of grow­ing up Jew­ish in the fad­ing Jazz Age. But the wealth of detail and colour­ful set­ting are a back­drop to the real heart of the book, which is the way that two very dif­fer­ent girls cau­tious­ly cir­cle each oth­er, as they try to decide whether a poten­tial friend­ship is worth the risk of hurt in their already-tumul­tuous lives. Shapiro per­fect­ly cap­tures the aching desire to be friends with a girl who’s way cool­er than you, just as she per­fect­ly cap­tures the slow real­iza­tion that effort­less cool­ness can be a front for des­per­ate­ly need­ing con­nec­tion and friend­ship. As the girls nav­i­gate their dif­fer­ences, their bur­geon­ing friend­ship, and — yes — Ida’s rela­tion­ship to her Jew­ish­ness, Hono­ria feels real, lived-in, and full of rich­ness for young and adult read­ers alike.