Fic­tion

The Oth­er

September 1, 2024

For Abe Dubin­s­ki and his fam­i­ly, life on the canal in New Jer­sey in 1933 was peace­ful and pro­duc­tive. The only Jew­ish fam­i­ly in the town, Abe is employed as a lock ten­der, respon­si­ble for the safe pas­sage of barges trav­el­ing from Penn­syl­va­nia to New York. The peace is shat­tered when a Nazi youth camp opens on the banks of the canal. Under the direc­tion of their Nazi lead­ers, one hun­dred teenage boys in brown shirts erect tents in the fields that abut Abe’s home. Abe Dubin­s­ki must take action to pro­tect his fam­i­ly, even if that action threat­ens his very soul. Nine­ty years lat­er, Char­lie Lev­en­son moves into the for­mer lock tender’s house, intent on liv­ing out his remain­ing years qui­et­ly after the death of his wife, Zoya Aziz. A series of threat­en­ing encoun­ters com­pels Char­lie to exam­ine the cir­cum­stances of his wife’s death. No mat­ter the cost, Char­lie has a respon­si­bil­i­ty to stand up to hate. What would you do to pro­tect your fam­i­ly when the Nazis come to town?

Discussion Questions

  1. The title of the book is The Oth­er. What is the sig­nif­i­cance of the book title? Who is the oth­er?
     
  2. When the Nazi youth camp opens, it cre­ates a moral dilem­ma for the bridge keep­er, Otto. Why is it impor­tant that Otto stands up for Abe Dubin­s­ki?
     
  3. What is the sym­bol­ism of the Shab­bos can­dles in the sto­ry?
     
  4. How does the his­to­ry of the Nazi youth camp inform the prob­lem of anti­semitism today?
     
  5. When Zoya says that it was Allah that brought her to the Barookhi­ans, what does she mean?
     
  6. Zoya believes that Jews and Mus­lims don’t have to be ene­mies. Do you think this is pos­si­ble today?
     
  7. The Oth­er has been described as a sto­ry of faith lost and faith found. Who los­es their faith? Who finds their faith? What does this mean to you as the read­er?
     
  8. What would you do to pro­tect your fam­i­ly when the Nazis come to town?
     
  9. When the rab­bi gives his ser­mon, he talks about the Know­able and the Unknow­able. What does he mean?
     
  10. The lock ten­der, Abe Dubinis­ki and his wife Miri­am have two teenage chil­dren, Man­ny and Rachel. Both chil­dren are changed for­ev­er by their encoun­ters with the Nazis at the youth camp. How do you imag­ine Man­ny and Rachel as adults?