Ann D. Koffsky and Pedro Rodríguez’s new chapter book about Harry Truman’s friendship with Eddie Jacobson introduces young readers to several events and concepts: Truman’s close ties to a Jewish clothing merchant and the United States’ recognition of Israel; the broader issues of prejudice, courage, and the way that personal relationships can affect public life; and learning to view history through the lens of a past era. From the meaning of the word “haberdasher” to the way antisemitism can be unthinkingly accepted, Koffsky and Rodríguez promote critical learning skills in an engaging and accessible story.
Harry Truman, who became president upon the death of Franklin Roosevelt, had the grave responsibility of leading his country through the end of the Second World War. Then, as American Jews and many of their non-Jewish fellow citizens embraced the idea of a Jewish state in Palestine, Truman was forced to confront an existential choice. Would the Jewish people, long exiled from their homeland and decimated by the Holocaust, be allowed to establish a sovereign nation? Truman’s background in the rural Midwest had not included many ties to Jewish communities. Even after he became an experienced Democratic politician, he harbored the casual antisemitism intrinsic to America at the time. But he did have one close attachment that ultimately combined with political pragmatism to influence his decision.
As a young man, Truman became friends with Eddie Jacobson when both were working in Kansas City, Missouri — Harry at a bank and Eddie at a dry goods store. After Harry returned to his family farm, the previously close friends lost contact but met again while serving in the army during World War I. Koffsky uses each chapter to raise questions, skillfully integrating different themes and encouraging children to approach historical figures as ordinary people facing challenges. Harry and Eddie open a store together with excitement and optimism, but an economic downturn leads to failure. Eddie remains in the clothing business, while Harry begins to build a career in politics. When his busy schedule allows a trip back home, he makes a point of visiting Eddie, “to play cards or music, go fishing … or meet up at Dixon’s Chili Parlor for some ribs.”
After describing two ordinary guys and their enduring affection for one another, Koffsky reveals their collision with history. One harbinger of tension is the chilling fact that Bess Truman, Harry’s wife, refuses to welcome Eddie to their home, even though he is her husband’s close friend. Koffsky does not specify the reason for this exclusion. Instead, she allows readers to infer it: “Eddie and his family could not understand it … They wondered if Bess didn’t like Jews. It was hard to know.” This petty hostility pales in comparison to the antisemitism in the aftermath of the war, when many Jews and their allies begin a concerted campaign to recognize a Jewish state in Palestine.
Now, Eddie Jacobson is pressured to take a stand by using his unique position to personally approach his friend, who has become stubbornly evasive about meeting future Israeli president Chaim Weizmann. The result of their collaboration is far more successful than their ill-fated clothing store.
Rodríguez’s pictures, influenced by comic book art, convey characters’ personalities through their expressive faces. Period details, from 1940s clothing to radios, immerse readers in an unfamiliar world with familiar emotions. One two-page spread shows a multicultural group of Americans writing letters in support of a Jewish state. Holding their fountain pens, these committed citizens are superimposed on a background of cursive writing and authentic postage stamps from the time. Each illustration, paired with Koffsky’s text, forms a cohesive and engaging picture of Jewish American history.
This highly recommended book includes an author’s note and a timeline.
Emily Schneider writes about literature, feminism, and culture for Tablet, The Forward, The Horn Book, and other publications, and writes about children’s books on her blog. She has a Ph.D. in Romance Languages and Literatures.