What makes a great theater memoir? Jeffrey Seller’s Theater Kid has it all — an engaging storyteller, a compelling rags-to-riches throughline, and a candid account of how it all happened. It’s also packed with insider details about his many stage productions.
Seller was adopted as a baby by Jewish parents in Michigan: a sometimes-violent father who bankrupted the family business and cheated on his wife, and a mother who worked at a drug store. The conflicts arising from those domestic tensions may well have sharpened Seller’s sense of the drama of everyday life.
It was Seller’s middle school music teacher who helped set the course of his life, casting him as a munchkin in a school production of The Wizard of Oz. Sellers had found his calling. Just a few months later, at age of twelve, he was cast in a play produced by the local professional theater company, Stagecrafters. Thanks to his talent for business as well as the stage, he later went on to produce some of Broadway’s biggest hits, including Rent, Avenue Q, In the Heights, and Hamilton.
In the first half of his memoir, Seller recalls the early signs of his future as a theater professional. When he was still a teenager, for example, he read a lot of plays as committee chair for a local children’s theater. In hindsight, he recognizes, the experience primed him to think about the plays’ box-office potential, not just the stories and the dialogue. With this kind of start, it’s no surprise that he became a master of the financial side of theatrical production.
The author is honest when discussing the long-standing issues in his family life. After his mother announced that she and his father were getting a divorce, Seller’s father asked him for a loan. Seller finally told his father what he had long felt: “You have failed as a father, you have failed as a husband. You’re a loser. Leave us alone. You’re finished.”
Seller is also candid about his own relationships. He recalls his confusion when an eighth-grade classmate said, “I think you’re gay.” Years later, when he was living with the composer/librettist Andrew Lippa, he reflected that “I have never said the words I am gay.”
The second half of the book offers a wealth of backstage stories about the numerous shows Seller has been involved with throughout his career. His keen insights, told in a direct, conversational style, are a must-read for theater aficionados and biography readers alike.
Bob Goldfarb is President Emeritus of Jewish Creativity International.