Non­fic­tion

Uncer­tain Empire: Jews, Nation­al­ism, and the Fate of British Imperialism

December 16, 2024

Fol­low­ing the British con­quest of Ottoman Pales­tine, Jews across the British Empire – from Jerusalem to Johan­nes­burg, Lon­don to Cal­cut­ta – found them­selves at the heart of glob­al Jew­ish polit­i­cal dis­course. As these intel­lec­tu­als, politi­cians, activists, and com­mu­nal elites nav­i­gat­ed shift­ing polit­i­cal land­scapes, some envi­sioned Pales­tine as a British domin­ion, lever­ag­ing impe­r­i­al pow­er for Jew­ish state-build­ing, while oth­ers fos­tered ties with anti­colo­nial move­ments, con­tem­plat­ing inde­pen­dent nation­al aspi­ra­tions. Uncer­tain Empire con­sid­ers this intri­cate inter­play between British impe­ri­al­ism, Zion­ism, and anti­colo­nial move­ments from the 1917 British con­quest of Pales­tine to the estab­lish­ment of the state of Israel in 1948.

Eliz­a­beth Imber high­lights diverse and some­times con­flict­ing visions of Jew­ish polit­i­cal futures, offer­ing detailed case stud­ies of key fig­ures includ­ing Chaim Arloso­roff, Moshe Sher­tok, Helen Ben­twich, Rachel Ezra, and Her­mann Kallen­bach. She explores a pol­i­tics of uncer­tain­ty” in which Jews engaged with both impe­r­i­al sta­bil­i­ty and the rise of anti­colo­nial mobi­liza­tion, when many were like­wise forced to recon­sid­er Pales­tine as a viable refuge and polit­i­cal solu­tion. Ulti­mate­ly, this book pro­vides a nuanced under­stand­ing of how the British Empire’s fate became cen­tral to Zion­ist and broad­er Jew­ish polit­i­cal thought, reveal­ing the com­plex inter­sec­tions of empire, state pow­er, and Jew­ish pol­i­tics dur­ing a time marked by pro­found urgency and exigency.

Discussion Questions

Uncer­tain Empire offers a deeply orig­i­nal refram­ing of Zion­ist his­to­ry through the lens­es of empire, nation­al­ism, and glob­al Jew­ish polit­i­cal life. Eliz­a­beth Imber’s mas­ter­ful use of archival sources across the British Empire, from Jerusalem and Johan­nes­burg to Lon­don and Cal­cut­ta, illu­mi­nates how Jew­ish lead­ers and com­mu­ni­ties nego­ti­at­ed com­pet­ing visions for Pales­tine under shift­ing impe­r­i­al and anti-colo­nial dynam­ics. By trac­ing con­crete case stud­ies of fig­ures such as Chaim Arloso­roff, Moshe Sher­tok, Helen Ben­twich, Rachel Ezra, and Her­mann Kallen­bach, Imber unpacks the pol­i­tics of uncer­tain­ty” that defined Jew­ish polit­i­cal thought between 1917 and 1948. The result is a rich­ly nuanced account that chal­lenges sim­pli­fied nar­ra­tives of Zion­ism, reveal­ing instead a com­plex mosa­ic of alliances, ambi­tions, and glob­al entan­gle­ments. In doing so, Uncer­tain Empire reshapes our under­stand­ing of the British Empire’s cen­tral — often con­tra­dic­to­ry — role in shap­ing mod­ern Jew­ish polit­i­cal iden­ti­ty, and mer­its the JDC-Katz­ki Award for its schol­ar­ly ambi­tion, method­olog­i­cal rig­or, and last­ing con­tri­bu­tion to mod­ern Jew­ish historiography.