
This piece is part of our Witnessing series, which shares pieces from Israeli authors and authors in Israel, as well as the experiences of Jewish writers around the globe in the aftermath of October 7th.
It is critical to understand history not just through the books that will be written later, but also through the first-hand testimonies and real-time accounting of events as they occur. At Jewish Book Council, we understand the value of these written testimonials and of sharing these individual experiences. It’s more important now than ever to give space to these voices and narratives.
October 7
From dark places
comes the murmur
of broken hearts.
Unspeakable words
that resurface
awakening suspended memory
reopening wounds barely healed.
And on this hallowed ground
you share your stories
risking so much
while we so little.
Transporting us back
to Kfar Aza, Nova, Sderot,
Re’im, Hostage Square
to honor those that have died
or have been taken.
To bear witness to that unfolding horror
as seen through your eyes.
Starbursts exploding in morning twilight
Shadows of bird men falling
onto rooftops and open fields
the ground shifting chaotically
as you are hunted.
Courageous and selfless acts silenced.
Your defenses not strong enough
to fight against so many monsters.
The choking smells of fire and ash
consume the air you breathe.
And through the smoke
houses collapse upon themselves
Indescribable cries
and the loss of innocence
confirm the presence
of evil everywhere.
Everyone trying to run somewhere
to save the life of another
to find family, neighbors, friends
to find comfort
to find shelter
to not be alone
to say a final goodbye
or just wanting to disappear
knowing that
what you love most
has been taken from you
Close by
the music suddenly dies.
Chilling sounds
of life being taken away
before its time.
Of last notes suspended in air
lingering before they vanish.
A bus filled with seniors
slaughtered at roadside
A police station going up in flames
All victims of terror
There are no rules
when it comes to killing Jews.
Unimaginable heinous acts
A day when 1200 lives were lost
and 2000 more were injured.
A day when 251 hostages were taken
and countless others missing.
A day that will never be forgotten.
A day you felt
abandoned by country
by the world
perhaps even by God.
A day when the earth
swallowed you whole
with humanity lost
amongst the rubble
Gaza War 18 Months Later
Even before the axis
tilted towards evil,
dancing began
in the streets
to the rhythm
of familiar tropes.
Hatred unmasked
spilling across the land
across oceans
filling the air we breathe
knowing no boundaries
leaving no one untouched
by fear and uncertainty.
A different planting season
with Jewish blood
still fresh on the ground.
And across generations
the earth stirred
gaining momentum,
as whispered voices grew stronger
speaking with each other
reminding us
that we have been here before.
And as you fought to survive
each day brought
more enemies who lined up
to destroy you.
From 7 fronts they came
terrorists only of different names
while the world condemned you
for defending yourself
You had hoped for more
but have learned
to expect less
It has been your longest war,
a complex war
the first fought
on your own soil.
Tragic loss
has made you
only grow stronger,
exposing paper tigers
while keeping wolves at bay.
And with your successes
inconsolable loss
and unbearable pain
As shabbat ends
wailing can be heard
from four corners
of hostage
square as
families gather to
find shelter and
comfort.
Crowds begin to swell
as night shadows fall.
Emotions raw
and palpable
often explosive,
light up the sky
Time measured by
the first hostages taken
and as the clock hand turns
crimson colored sand
sifts through
an hourglass.
The rhythmic sound
of heartbeats slowing
some hostages brought back alive
while for others
only their remains.
A sense that time
is running out.
A tragic and collective reminder
of what has been lost
and taken from you.
Your voices lifted upward
unsure if words
will be heard…
“enough enough“ you cry out
“bring the hostages home now!”
“we are with you, you are not alone”
The emotional landscape
within your borders
has made this war
even more complex
Building a consensus
replaced by suspicion
and doubt
The best way forward
often nuanced.
Dividing the country
when unity so desperately needed
So that you may heal
and move forward together.
Hope
We are here as witness
not to judge.
A blessing
to hear inspirational stories
of your courage
and resiliency.
How you see light
through your tears
while sifting through the darkness
of your lives
An orange
placed at the
gravesite of your
wife,
becomes a life force.
Scrambling eggs in a kitchen
reminds you of what it feels like
to be safe in your home.
Building a city of Legos
becomes a symbol
of endless possibilities.
A bottle of wine purchased for soldiers
a show of gratitude.
Reaching across enemy lines
to focus on shared values.
Taking control back
one step at a time
through countless loving acts of doing.
Providing supplies or food for soldiers
for the hungry
for the sick
Ensuring social services and counseling
for those in desperate need of aid.
Tying tzitzit on the uniforms
of those in harm’s way.
Telling your stories
that elevate us and others around you
as you rebuild your world.
You have given us so much
and have asked for so little
We have all been touched
but need to help you
move forward
before the freshness of memory fades
Your actions are a challenge for all of us
to find a role in the act of doing
to help in any way we can
And, if we do not
who are we…
We are with you, you are not alone…
The views and opinions expressed above are those of the author, based on their observations and experiences.
Support the work of Jewish Book Council and become a member today.
Robert Moss is a physician who has practiced medicine for forty-five years in the northern suburbs of Chicago. The poem “Witness” was written after a recent volunteer and solidarity mission trip to Israel. It is dedicated to the remarkable courage, strength, and resilience of all Israelis and Jews around the world, who manage to find light even in the darkest of moments now and throughout their history.