Non­fic­tion

A World of Piety: The Aims of Castil­ian Kabbalah

December 23, 2024

A World of Piety exam­ines the his­tor­i­cal aspi­ra­tions of kab­bal­ah to prompt a revival of ancient rab­binic piety in medieval Castile.

What were the aims of the cel­e­brat­ed works of rab­binic wis­dom fash­ioned dur­ing the reigns of Alfon­so X and San­cho IV of Castile, includ­ing the for­ma­tive Book of the Zohar? In pur­suit of this ques­tion, Judaica schol­ar Jere­my Phillip Brown turns to the Hebrew and Ara­ma­ic writ­ings com­posed by Todros ben Joseph ha-Levi Abu­lafia of Tole­do, Joseph Gikatil­la of Med­i­naceli, and espe­cial­ly Moses de León of Guadala­jara. These writ­ings set out to dis­sem­i­nate the secret pat­ri­mo­ny of ancients: a knowl­edge of divin­i­ty com­prised of essen­tial­ly Jew­ish attrib­ut­es as a basis for human emu­la­tion. Accord­ing to these texts, God mod­els a pious form of life-not mere­ly a life of Torah and the com­mand­ments, but a pro­gram exceed­ing the norms of reli­gious oblig­a­tion. Mid­night vig­ils for prayer and study, guard­ing the eyes and tongue, sex­u­al aus­ter­i­ty, spir­i­tu­al pover­ty and con­cern for the mate­ri­al­ly poor-the texts affirm that God exem­pli­fies these and oth­er modes of piety, prompt­ing their imi­ta­tion as a pen­i­ten­tial means of indi­vid­ual and even social­trans­for­ma­tion. By means of their writ­ings, the Castil­ian authors sought to form pen­i­tents as oth­er peo­ple” cre­at­ed anew in the Judeo­mor­phic image of God. A World of Piety sheds light on the core moti­va­tions of a dis­course that would emerge as a major domain of reli­gion and thought by recon­struct­ing the socio-his­tor­i­cal ambi­tions of a lit­tle-known cadre of medieval rab­bis active in a Chris­t­ian milieu.

Discussion Questions

In a World of Piety: The Aims of Castil­ian Piety, Jere­my Phillip Brown pro­pos­es a ground­break­ing new read­ing of Moses de Leon’s Zohar and oth­er thir­teen-cen­tu­ry Castil­ian Kab­bal­is­tic tracts. Rather than under­stand­ing these Span­ish mys­ti­cal texts as intend­ed pri­mar­i­ly to reveal the com­plex intra-divine dynam­ics of the ten-pow­er god­head, as schol­ar­ship has until now pre­sup­posed, Brown reads them, first and fore­most, as pietist works aimed at cul­ti­vat­ing repen­tance and Jew­ish devo­tion. In Brown’s view, thir­teenth-cen­tu­ry Castil­ian Kab­bal­ists sought to deci­pher the var­i­ous inter­ac­tions between the divine sefirot not as an end to itself (theos­o­phy) but as a nec­es­sary first step in pro­duc­ing an accu­rate depic­tion of divine attrib­ut­es that could be emu­lat­ed by Jews through per­form­ing pen­i­ten­tial and pietis­tic devo­tion­al acts. To sup­port his revi­sion­ist read­ing, Brown insight­ful­ly shows the ways Castil­ian mys­tics, like de Leon and Joseph Gikatil­la, inte­grat­ed pri­or Proven­cal and Cat­alon­ian Kab­bal­is­tic ideas into their own pre-theo­soph­i­cal (neo-Mai­monidean) moral notions to pro­duce a unique Castil­ian blend of Kab­bal­is­tic piety.