The Threshold Singers are a small group of vocalists that count author Brenda Miller as a member; they gather around the bedsides of those in hospitals or hospice. The group sings in unison, meeting the patient where they are in that moment; sometimes it’s a lullaby, quietly murmured; sometimes it’s a song requested by the patient; sometimes it’s just a melody hummed. Miller notes that the singers are there to bear witness and help someone cross a threshold — in this case, the threshold from life into death.
An apt subtitle for this exquisite collection of essays and poetry from the award-winning Brenda Miller could be “threshold.” Throughout the book, Miller invites us to cross a threshold with her, albeit a different sort of divide into the chapters of her life. The reader accompanies her on her journey of unexpected caretaking. Miller’s storytelling is raw, intimate, and moving; this story is an elegy to her parents, the person that she was, and even her beloved dog.
Miller weaves together timelines throughout her story — the first part is focused on taking care of her father. Subsequently, the narrative hones in on her time caring for her mother in the wake of her father’s death. Miller expertly intertwines stories of her younger, more rebellious self with tales of her adult life. We meet her dog, her neighbors, and her friends with colorful details; we see the frog paraphernalia that her parents collected over a lifetime, and the hummingbirds that kept her mother company.
It is a life well-lived, told through short essays and poems. My favorite poem, entitled “Pantoum for Elderly Women,” is just that: a pantoum, a poem of interlocking four-line stanzas where lines 2 and 4 of a stanza then become lines 1 and 3 of the next stanza, for the entirety of the poem. This piece is a beautiful commentary on aging and nature, made more poignant with the interesting structure.
Ultimately, Miller writes with a grace and simplicity that helps to soften the heavy subject of grief, which is notoriously challenging to write about in an accessible way. Almost without realizing it — like with the beautiful quiet music of the Threshold Singers — the reader is lulled into her fascinating and heartfelt story.
Dr. Beth Ricanati is a physician, speaker and the author of Braided: A Journey of a Thousand Challahs, a finalist for the National Jewish Book Award.