Fic­tion

The Col­lect­ed Works of Esther Kreitman

  • Review
By – April 13, 2026

This vol­ume brings togeth­er, for the first time, the two major nov­els and col­lect­ed short sto­ries of Esther Kre­it­man (1891 – 1954), known in Yid­dish as Hinde Ester Singer Kreyt­man, the old­er sis­ter of Isaac Bashe­vis Singer and Israel Joshua Singer. Until rel­a­tive­ly recent­ly, Kreitman’s work was at best con­sid­ered a foot­note to the work of her more acclaimed broth­ers, espe­cial­ly I. B. Singer, win­ner of the Nobel Prize. The devel­op­ment of fem­i­nist schol­ar­ship has done much to res­ur­rect Kreitman’s fic­tion and to place it in the con­text of a rich lit­er­ary her­itage both in Yid­dish and Euro­pean literature.

Kreitman’s two nov­els emerge from the cir­cum­stances of her own life. Born in the shtetl world described in her broth­ers’ fic­tion and mem­oirs, she was sent off to an arranged mar­riage to an Antwerp dia­mond cut­ter. The out­break of World War I sent the cou­ple to Eng­land, where Kre­it­man lived for the bet­ter part of the rest of her life. By all accounts, hers was not a hap­py mar­riage and nei­ther she nor her hus­band made an ade­quate liv­ing. She con­tributed short sto­ries to Yid­dish pub­li­ca­tions in Eng­land and Poland and pub­lished her two nov­els with­out attain­ing much recog­ni­tion. The first trans­la­tions of her work began to appear in the years after World War II

Her first nov­el, The Dance of the Demons (Der Shey­dim Tants; orig­i­nal­ly titled Devoyrele) tells a sto­ry that in out­line mir­rors Kreitman’s ear­ly life. Deb­o­rah (Devoyrele) is the daugh­ter of a small-town rab­bi and his edu­cat­ed but sick­ly wife. The grind­ing pover­ty of the Pol­ish shtetl and the lim­it­ed hori­zons set before a young Jew­ish girl of the ear­ly twen­ti­eth cen­tu­ry are laid out in blis­ter­ing detail. The fam­i­ly moves sev­er­al times before wind­ing up in War­saw, where their prospects don’t improve sig­nif­i­cant­ly. Deb­o­rah attempts to escape from the trap of her life by dab­bling in Social­ism, and then when that fails to lib­er­ate her, she agrees to an arranged mar­riage to an Antwerp dia­mond cut­ter. That mar­riage turns out to be anoth­er trap and the nov­el ends with Deb­o­rah and her hus­band fac­ing the immi­nent Ger­man inva­sion of Belgium.

The sec­ond nov­el, Dia­monds (Brilyantn), set in the Antwerp Jew­ish com­mu­ni­ty of dia­mond mer­chants and work­ers, draws a broad­er por­trait of Jew­ish life. Cen­tered on the fam­i­ly of a wealthy and some­what unscrupu­lous mer­chant named Gedali­ah Berman, the nov­el describes the ten­sions between Berman and his chil­dren, the machi­na­tions of the dia­mond mar­ket, and the pover­ty and exploita­tion of many of the work­ers. The Ger­man inva­sion of 1914 sends Berman and fam­i­ly to seek refuge in Eng­land, where Berman tries to reestab­lish his busi­ness and keep his fam­i­ly togeth­er. While he suc­ceeds mate­ri­al­ly, he is left at the end of the nov­el with his per­son­al rela­tions shat­tered. HIs wife (whom he reg­u­lar­ly dis­par­aged) dies, his son rejects him, and his father leaves behind a damn­ing note repu­di­at­ing him.

Influ­enced to some extent by the fic­tion of Charles Dick­ens, Kre­it­man is at her strongest depict­ing the social forces affect­ing the char­ac­ters, espe­cial­ly the women. Deborah’s lim­it­ed hori­zons are mir­rored to some extent in the plight of Gitele, a young girl in Dia­monds, who has a child out of wed­lock with Berman’s son and lives a life of grind­ing pover­ty with her com­mon-law hus­band, a social­ist orga­niz­er. Berman’s daugh­ter Jean­nette is pushed into an arranged mar­riage with an old­er man when she becomes preg­nant with the child of a non-Jew­ish lover. Mrs. Berman is a sad char­ac­ter liv­ing under the thumb of her impe­ri­ous husband.

Kreitman’s plot devel­op­ment isn’t always sure-foot­ed. Scenes in both nov­els occa­sion­al­ly go on longer than they need to or are some­times heavy-hand­ed in their satire of social pre­ten­sions (espe­cial­ly in Dia­monds). But the accu­mu­la­tion of detail and the emo­tion­al under­pin­nings make their impact felt and the nov­els hold their own as social por­traits of a lost world.

Mar­tin Green is pro­fes­sor emer­i­tus at Fair­leigh Dick­in­son Uni­ver­si­ty, where he taught lit­er­a­ture and media stud­ies. He is work­ing on a book about Amer­i­can pop­u­lar peri­od­i­cals in the 1920s.

Discussion Questions