Richard Michelson and Stacy Innerst’s highly recommended picture book biography of Louis Brandeis captures the impressive core of his accomplishments. As the subtitle cleverly declares, this crusading advocate for the rights of workers, women, Jews, and all Americans rose to the highest professional position, as a Justice of the Supreme Court. Each page of text gives evidence of his skills, intelligence, and persistence, and every illustration converts an icon into a complex human being.
On the cover, Brandeis carefully holds a balanced scale, which represents his ideals. With one foot atop a pile of books, he has ascended through his education. The black robe associated with his career swings behind him like a magician’s cape; the breadth of Brandeis’s achievements, rooted in pragmatism and principle, almost defies belief. His German Jewish family was financially privileged, yet antisemitism was a constant obstacle in his striving for success. Michelson repeatedly uses the phrase “any fool knows,” when reporting the advice of Brandeis’s parents, who emphasized values of equality, honesty, and common sense.
Nineteenth-century America included different models for Jewish identity. Brandeis’s background was decidedly not traditionally observant; his parents were assimilated to the point of celebrating Christmas. At his uncle’s house, however, kosher laws and Sabbath rituals were honored. Regardless, the degree to which one practiced Judaism did not alter the antisemitism one faced. The only Jew in his class at Harvard Law School, as well as the youngest student, Brandeis stood out academically. What Louis Brandeis Knows shows that, as his career advanced, he remained aware that Jewish ethnicity conferred a marginalized status.
Michelson explains the context of Brandeis’s legal work in the Progressive Movement. In the early twentieth century, many Americans became committed to addressing economic inequality, through labor unions, social activism, and legal challenges. Brandeis’s reliance on data and social context in framing his arguments was so important that it became known as the “Brandeis brief.” When monopolistic corporations used their power to oppress working people, Brandeis championed the underdog and won significant victories that protected their rights. When President Woodrow Wilson nominated him for a position on the Supreme Court, representatives of the powerful forces that he had challenged opposed his nomination. Nevertheless, he was approved by the Senate, and became the first Jewish Supreme Court Justice.
Louis Brandeis was also a leader of the Zionist movement well before it was more broadly accepted by American Jews. Michelson briefly mentions calls for a Jewish homeland in the text, and gives further detail about Brandeis’s role in the book’s afterword and timeline. While the far-reaching influence of his legal decisions might be his most significant contributions to American history, his unrelenting defense of a democratic Jewish state is consistent with the rest of his legacy.
Illustrations of Brandeis alternate with equally evocative scenes of other Americans. Somber figures of Jewish refugees enter the United States in a great wave of immigration. Striking workers hold up signs demanding their rights. Women working long hours at tedious tasks concentrate on their work. Throughout, Innerst emphasizes the dignity of Brandeis’s demeanor, along with his compassion for the vast number of citizens who needed his advocacy to support their own movements for change.
Emily Schneider writes about literature, feminism, and culture for Tablet, The Forward, The Horn Book, and other publications, and writes about children’s books on her blog. She has a Ph.D. in Romance Languages and Literatures.