Selina Alko has written and illustrated a truly great picture book dedicated to the inimitable children’s book author Judy Blume. The book’s unusual structure, a series of poems built around key events and people in Blume’s childhood, invites readers into the young life of a future icon. Inventive titles for each poem, many alluding to Blume’s own books, add a dimension that encourages intergenerational sharing. Alko’s illustrations, with their colorful and bold images, brings her subject’s formative years to life.
“Judy the Great” was born Judith Sussman, in 1938, in Elizabeth, New Jersey. She was a bookish girl who immersed herself in the tales of Nancy Drew and Ludwig Bemelmans’s Madeline. In Alko’s poem “Tales of a Fourth Grade Reader,” young Judy identifies with her literary heroines. Pictured sitting on top of a volume, lost in a book herself, Judy heads a group of her favorite characters. A two-page spread entitled “Unlikely Events” is a reference to one of Blume’s novels for adults, based on a frightening and inexplicable series of air crashes that devastated her community. Like Blume herself, Alko does not avoid uncomfortable material, although she emphasizes how Judy integrated troubling feelings and adapted to circumstances.
Some poems combine plot elements from Blume’s books and their relevance to her life. “End of Sentence” is clever and short, an homage to Blume’s frank discussion of menstruation in Are You There God?” It’s Me, Margaret. Blume’s commitment to openly addressing this and other once-taboo topics in books for young readers has earned her a perennial place on lists of banned books. Here, Alko cleverly pictures Judy waiting for her first period, without actually specifying the nature of this life-changing milestone. The illustration shows a girl with her hands clasped over the word “MY” in large bold font, implying a healthy sense of ownership over her body.
In “Holidays,” Judy finds the Christmas atmosphere in New York City exciting. Traveling “twenty-seven minutes by train to Penn Station” brings her close to such wonders of the dominant culture as the Rockefeller Center Tree, but this does not displace her family’s celebration of Hanukkah. Jewish ceremonies surrounding death are also a prominent part of her childhood, including the seven days of mourning, where family and friends “sat and ate and mourned.” Judy’s fears about her father’s failing health are always present. Alko’s depiction of a shiva shows Judy seated on a couch with family members, her father’s arm protectively encircling her. The table is covered with bagels, black-and-white cookies, and halvah, and the expression on Judy’s face reveals the contradiction between sadness and appreciation of the abundance of delicious food.
Finally Judy grows up, as announced in the poem, “Judy Blooms.” Seated at a typewriter, the newly confident author produces the books that have made her famous, each one emerging from a leafy branch as they have from her imagination and experiences.
Otherwise Known as Judy the Great is highly recommended and includes an author’s note, timeline, photographs, and list of sources.
Emily Schneider writes about literature, feminism, and culture for Tablet, The Forward, The Horn Book, and other publications, and writes about children’s books on her blog. She has a Ph.D. in Romance Languages and Literatures.