Fic­tion

An Admirable Woman

  • Review
By – November 2, 2026

Arthur Cohen’s An Admirable Woman, which won the Nation­al Jew­ish Book Award for Fic­tion in 1983, is now avail­able in a time­ly new edi­tion. The nov­el explores the life of Eri­ka Hertz, a fic­tion­al Ger­man Jew­ish woman who leaves Ger­many before World War II breaks out, moves to New York, and becomes an intel­lec­tu­al force — a pro­fes­sor, a writer, a philoso­pher. Before she leaves, Erika’s fam­i­ly is deeply assim­i­lat­ed into Ger­man soci­ety, but when the Nazi par­ty comes to pow­er, she real­izes she must escape. Her plan is sim­ple: she and her hus­band, Martens, will pre­tend to go to France on vaca­tion and nev­er return. When they stop in at her par­ents’ house for one last good­bye, her par­ents real­ize what she is plan­ning and are dev­as­tat­ed. They can­not under­stand why she would decide to get out. They are Ger­man above all else. Where else could they pos­si­bly go?

But of course, we know what would have hap­pened to Eri­ka if she had stayed in Ger­many. And she learns, too, through her par­ents’ expe­ri­ences. Through­out the book, Cohen presents paths for Eri­ka. No mat­ter which road she choos­es, he always reminds us that anoth­er ver­sion of her, the oth­er who took the oth­er fork, could exist. Choic­es, he seems to say, do not have a nar­row­ing effect. Instead, they expand our lives.

This is a nov­el of diver­gence. Cohen’s pro­tag­o­nist is based on Han­nah Arendt, the Ger­man Jew­ish the­o­rist, writer, and philoso­pher. Eri­ka is a fic­tion­al­ized ver­sion, a per­son Arendt could have been if she had done things dif­fer­ent­ly. Erika’s life speaks to the cen­tral the­sis of the nov­el: that we are all a prod­uct of the choic­es we make. 

At the end of the book, Cohen shows an aging Eri­ka, and uncov­ers the ways in which the weight of her life­time of deci­sions has impact­ed her phys­i­cal­ly. Eri­ka is pri­mar­i­ly a thinker, a per­son of the mind, but ulti­mate­ly it is her body that deter­mines her mind’s abil­i­ty. The choic­es we make have a phys­i­cal impact on us, where we live, and what we endure. It is these fac­tors, more than what we think, that in the end define us most.

Discussion Questions