In Heidi Shertok’s romance novel Match Me If You Can, matchmaker Ashiva finds herself in trouble: she’s made a huge faux-pas with a powerful Jewish family in Brooklyn while attempting to find a match for their daughter. This leads to her matchmaking business crumbling, as the family disparages her name across the Orthodox community. Scrounging around for a way to fix things, Ashiva decides that she’ll find a match for her friend Caleb, an exceptionally eligible and prized bachelor, to get her business back off the ground. The only complication is that the two have a long history together, and he might want to be with her more than any of the women she sets him up with.
Protagonist Ashiva is endearing, funny, and bubbly; she is constantly putting her foot in her mouth, which leads to many laugh-out-loud scenes. The tone of the book mixes sweetness and hilarity, as readers watch Ashiva dress up in disguise to eavesdrop on a date on more than one occasion. he characters that surround her — from the kvetching, foul-mouthed widow Bernice, to her belligerent yet endearing best friend Sissel — are equally endearing in their own ways.
Match Me If You Can is a quick-paced joy to read, depicting Orthodox Brooklyn in a fully-realized manner. Jewish law is brought in through multiple contexts, as are the variations in Jewish custom and practice, most evidently present in the contrast between Ashiva and Caleb’s backgrounds, with Ashiva being Ashkenazi and Caleb being both Ashkenazi and Ethiopian. Match Me If You Can earns a laudable place in the canon of Jewish romance fiction.
Benjamin Selesnick is a psychotherapist in New Jersey. His writing has appeared in Barely South Review, Lunch Ticket, Tel Aviv Review of Books, and other publications. He holds an MFA in fiction from Rutgers University-Newark.