In 1951, the Hula Drainage Project began to convert wetlands into available space for housing and agriculture. Unfortunately, this process led to the destruction of a crucial ecosystem. An unusual amphibian, the painted frog, disappeared and was believed to have gone extinct. When a painted frog turned up in Israel’s Hula Valley in 2011, scientists were surprised and thrilled. In Amber A. Novak and Maya Gonen’s highly recommended and informational picture book, the narrator is a talkative painted frog, encouraging the fellow members of his species to learn their history and appreciate their importance.
An engaging tone defines the book. Adopting the conceit that the frogs are as indifferent as some humans, the narrator appeals to both their self-interest and sense of responsibility to others. Like a stand-up comic trying to capture the attention of an audience, the frog challenges them: “You! Over there! Is your third eyelid closing? Stay awake! This is the story of who you are.” Maya Gonen’s creatures, with colors complementing their surroundings, have expressive features, as do the humans who interact with them. Determined to accomplish their goals, and later saddened by the unintended consequences, these Israelis are finally depicted as activists working together.
Describing their original home as a veritable Garden of Eden, the frog paints a picture of ecological balance, with “delightfully stinky marshes” and “delicious mosquitos” which were perfect for frogs, but less so for humans. Pictures of well-intentioned workers plagued by mosquito bites shows that humans were not villains. They were trying to improve their country through development, but failed to anticipate all the consequences. The “giant metal claws” of their equipment turned the lake into dry land. “Noisy engines” frightened away the ducks. From the point of view of Hula painted frogs, their home is now a wasteland.
But frogs, like people, are resilient. The narrator reports that, “against all odds,” some frogs have survived, leaving the potential for renewal. There is a subtle change of tone from description to a clear message, with the frog declaring that, working together, people can bring positive changes. The result is Israel’s first nature preserve, where a park ranger spots one hardy survivor: mottled, bumpy, and beautiful. Science and poetry mix in the frog’s lyrical celebration of a species that has come back to life, ready to jump, sing, and play in its mucky, soggy, bog. Human beings are not perfect, he concedes, but they need to be encouraged in their commitment to acknowledge mistakes and set things right.
The book includes an afterword with additional information.
Emily Schneider writes about literature, feminism, and culture for Tablet, The Forward, The Horn Book, and other publications, and writes about children’s books on her blog. She has a Ph.D. in Romance Languages and Literatures.